Connecting Texas books and writers with those who most want to discover them

Lone Star Book Reviews
By Michelle Newby, NBCC
Contributing Editor

 

Michelle Newby is a reviewer for Kirkus Reviews and Foreword Reviews, writer, blogger at TexasBookLover.com, member of the Permian Basin Writers' Workshop advisory committee, and a moderator for the Texas Book Festival. Her reviews appear in Pleiades Magazine, Rain Taxi, Concho River Review, Mosaic Literary Magazine, Atticus Review, The Rumpus, PANK Magazine, and The Collagist.

 

Lone Star Book Reviews
of Texas books appear weekly
at LoneStarLiterary.com

DAVID COLLINS taught English for forty years at Westminster College in Missouri. He has had unrestricted access to all materials related to the story of Mark Phariss and Vic Holmes, including legal communications and documents, and conducted extensive interviews with Mark and Vic and others involved in the case. He lives in Pineville, North Carolina.

10.15.2017

CIVIL RIGHTS

David Collins, with foreword by Evan Wolfson and Julian Castro

Accidental Activists: Mark Phariss, Vic Holmes, and Their Fight for Marriage Equality in Texas

University of North Texas Press

Hardcover, 978-1-5744-1692-3 (also available as an e-book and on Audible), 480 pgs., $29.95

August 15, 2017

 

 

On June 26, 2015, the Supreme Court of the United States affirmed the right to marry for all Americans in Obergefell v. Hodges, after forty years of “struggle and engagement, combat and persuasion, activism and conversation.” Almost six hundred couples have been plaintiffs in same-sex marriage cases since 1970. In 2013, Mark Phariss and Vic Holmes of Plano, along with Cleopatra DeLeon and Nicole Dimetman of Austin, agreed to become named plaintiffs for a Texas case. Phariss and Holmes were denied a marriage license in Bexar County, and powerhouse international law firm Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld, LLP, promptly filed suit. (Full disclosure: this reviewer proudly worked for Akin Gump for ten years.)

 

Accidental Activists: Mark Phariss, Vic Holmes, and Their Fight for Marriage Equality in Texas by David Collins, with a foreword by Evan Wolfson, founder and president of Freedom to Marry, and Julian Castro, former Secretary of Housing and Urban Development and former mayor of San Antonio, is the newest volume in the Mayborn Literary Nonfiction Series from the University of North Texas Press. Accidental Activists is an important addition to a more complete understanding and appreciation of the history of all Texans.

 

Collins’s writing is entertaining, employing a literary-nonfiction style that makes Accidental Activists read like a novel. Don’t expect neutrality; Accidental Activists is not journalism. Collins engagingly relates the biographies of “reluctant rebels” Phariss, a corporate attorney and human rights activist, and Holmes, a physician’s assistant, professor, and twenty-three-year veteran of the United States Air Force. Collins commands empathy as he tells the story of Mark and Vic’s eighteen-year relationship, a tale of breathtaking prejudice and dumbfounding ignorance, as well as a tale of passionate love, precious kindness, and enduring commitment.

 

There are moments in Accidental Activists when the narrative threatens to bog down in legal terminology, quotes from Justice Antonin Scalia’s scorching dissents, and repetition, but such is the nature of the law, and proof of Collins’s exhaustive research. A more careful copyedit of this title before its next printing might fix the occasional typo, but one particular instance deserves note, to remedy likely confusion: incorrect citation of 2015 for the United States v. Windsor case on page 188 throws off the timeline and sent me scrambling to the index for the correct year, 2013.

 

Elsewhere, Collins’s weaving of national, state, and personal history is quite skillful. His analysis of future challenges involving the chimera of threats to religious freedom, and the “dark comedy” of simultaneous claims to, and abandonment of, the concept of local control, is clear. As noted in the foreword by Wolfson and Castro, Americans need to remain vigilant in the struggle with “bad policies, bad politics, [and] bad politicians,” because, as President Barack Obama warned, and we have witnessed during the last several months, progress isn’t “inevitable … History doesn’t just travel forward; it can go backwards if we don’t work hard.”

 

But for now, for just a little while, let’s enjoy Accidental Activists. Collins’s exuberant love of Shakespeare is infectious, and through his judicious use of anecdotes—no small number starring the beloved beagles (see photographs)—the personalities of Phariss and Holmes beam from these pages.

 

* * * * *

 

 

LONE STAR LITERARY LIFE   copyright © 2015–17 Paragraph Ranch LLC  •  All rights reserved  •  CONTACT US